Two Contrasting Plays at NYC’s Public Theater

Starting in 1960, Joseph Papp upended the non-profit theater world with what would become New York’s Public Theater.  The Public would be noteworthy if only for two of its most memorable launches, Hair and A Chorus Line, but it has participated in the creation of scores more while also reviving many noted plays, especially from the Shakespeare canon.

THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON

(foreground) Andrew Durand as Benjamin, Kelsee Kimmel as Elowen. All photos by Joan Marcus.

Among the current offerings, The Public is producing a revival of the musical version of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. For those unfamiliar, the premise is that Benjamin is born an old man who is hidden away by his parents, and who instead of growing older, grows younger.  He would ultimately spring free from his constraints, marry, have children, and share the joys and tragedies of life, while hiding his unique life cycle.

The original source material is from a short story by F. Scott Fitzgerald, who places the initial action in Baltimore, whereas the popular movie from 2008 is based in New Orleans.  British are behind the musical.  The book is composed by Jethro Compton, with music by Darren Clark, and it commences in Cornwall before spreading to other English locales and ultimately to New England.

The joyous and uplifting musical has much to commend it.  The story moves quickly, supported by perky music in the modern English folk vein, and the West End version won three Olivier Awards.

The cast at The Public soars with talent and high energy, led by the accomplished Andrew Durand as Benjamin and Kelsee Kimmel as Elowen, the woman he would marry.  Another standout is Sachiko Mae, who plays multiple roles, starting with Mary, Benjamin’s mother, who would take her own life, distressed by the birth of a son old enough to be her grandfather.

Sachiko Mae as Mary.

The overall feel of the story is uplifting, with many sensitive moments, as Benjamin often faces rejection of the kind that many minorities are accustomed to.  In one instance, Benjamin provided support for an oppressed sailor called Young Jack when the latter was a teen. But when Benjamin meets the same man who against expectation has become a captain, Jack dismisses Benjamin, as he can’t reconcile the empathetic old man he knew before and the younger one he sees before him.

The performance I attended received a standing O.  Together with its unique plotline and accolades, how can one not give a positive recommendation?

Here is where I object to much philosophy of theater criticism, particularly the notion that a critic should be the undisputed arbiter of worthiness, especially when competent critics frequently disagree on evaluation of elements and overall worth.  Many critics express their subjective opinions as if they are objective and unassailable.  Particularly in the New York market, where the Times’ primary critic has been a God absent doubt or humility, a bad review often sinks a production, and along with it, tens of jobs and millions of dollars.  And you know what?  The critic may have just had an argument with their spouse or be having a bad reaction from the dinner that they ate

That said, here are the reasons that Button didn’t work as well for me as for others, some of which you may like or not.  Overall, it is so full of conceits and devices, that it seems formulaic.  Of course, the very premise is a brilliant and unique conceit that is the sine qua non.  In the film, extensive makeup is used to vary Brad Pitt’s appearance of age, but in this case none is used, not even a gray wig to signify age.  To his credit, Durand does a fine job using expression, movement, and gesticulation to distinguish the many ages he reverses through.

Cast.

Several aspects of the design are so conspicuous that the devices become self-referential.  One is storytelling by committee, in which the monologue baton is passed on every couple of sentences in the frequent orations.  Another is that in virtually every narrative interruption, a date and time stamp is ceremoniously announced right down to the minute.

To show enthusiasm, despite micing, speakers shout at the top of their lungs.  Rather than leaving the stage when they are inactive, the actors always hang around the set, which looks like a dilapidated refuge from The Pirates of Penzance. Good reasons for cast to remain are that each cast member is a musician (another conspicuous device), virtually all multi-instrumental, and they provide the near-continuous ambient music, chorus singing, as well as background to songs.

As noted, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button has received considerable support and will suit the demands of most theatergoers, but you are forewarned of the recurring self-parody devices.  More commentary follows below.

WE’LL SEE

Two decades ago, Oskar Eustice, then new Artistic Director of The Public Theater commissioned Richard Nelson who proposed a series of intimate plays about how people process important events.  We’ll See offers his 13th play centering on domestic life in Rhinebeck, New York, a historic town on the Hudson River, 100 miles north of New York City.

In many ways, We’ll See is the polar opposite of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.  The former takes place in one room in one evening; the latter in numerous English cities, at sea, and in New Hampshire over 80 years.  We’ll See involves four elderly siblings and a friend played by five actors in a talkathon.  Button has 40 characters from the panoply of life played by 11 actors having multiple roles.  The play is very naturalistic, quiet, and static and performed on a small stage in the round.  The musical is stylistic and raucous with song and heavily coordinated movement on a large proscenium arch stage.

Jay O. Sanders as Richard, Sally Murphy as Jane, Laila Robins as Marian, Maryann Plunkett as Barbara.

Time is significant to Nelson in We’ll See as well, but in a different way.  Each of the 13 plays of the Rhinebeck Panorama has opened on the same day as the action, in this case, November 3, 2026, election day.  We peer into the interactions of the Apples, a politically liberal family.  Richard, the only brother, has actually worked for former Democratic Governor Andrew Cuomo.

The family has gathered for dinner with great trepidation about the elections of the day, and a key feature of the play is that it was written before the outcome was known, so the characters can only speculate on what the audience knows has happened.  While they are concerned and informed politically, one rule the siblings agree to is that no one will mention “his” name, knowing the outsized play it usually gets.

More than politics, most of their discussions concern their daily life as they actually share a meal.  Each of them is put upon in different ways, and each demands respect in different ways.  Richard (Jay O. Sanders) talks of his recent trip to Paris.  Seventy-four-year-old Barbara (Maryann Plunkett) tells that she has been railroaded into accepting retirement from teaching at the end of the semester.  Middle female, Marian, (Laila Robins) tries to keep socially active, while the youngest, Jane (Sally Murphy), is living with her boyfriend in the City and in Rhinebeck.  She and Richard are actively writing a history of their one-traffic-light town and unearthing interesting tidbits, but she also discloses that she hasn’t voted, which causes considerable consternation and discussion.

Richard’s younger girlfriend, the appropriately raspy voiced Yvonne (Yvonne Woods), joins later.  She is an aspiring stage actress, but in an anomalous twist of fate, she is the one who suffers what is known to be a terminal cancer.

Jay O. Sanders as Richard, Yvonne Woods as Yvonne, Sally Murphy as Jane, Laila Robins as Marian.

We’ll See has little at stake; divulges little of substance; and lacks a conclusive outcome.  Yet, this intimate narrative reveals interactions among people of a certain age at a certain time that has meaning as part of the kaleidoscope of American life.  It is completely convincing, in part due to fine acting from a great ensemble led by husband-and-wife team Jay O. Sanders and Maryann Plunkett who have earned a NY Critics Circle Joint Lifetime Achievement Award.

One housekeeping concern is that acoustics in the theater are tricky, and much dialog can be lost, especially when the speaker is facing away.  For those with any hearing deficiency, avail the listening aids.

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, with book and lyrics by Jethro Compton and music and lyrics by Darren Clark, plays through December 6, 2026.

We’ll See, written by Richard Nelson, plays through November 29, 2026. Both plays are produced by Public Theater and performed on its stages at 425 Lafayette Street, New York, NY

Erie Mills: A Tribute

Erie Mills.

Erie Mills, brilliant coloratura soprano, musical and opera star, teacher and mentor, diction coach, and Artistic Director of Livermore Valley Opera for 18 years, died of pulmonary fibrosis at age 73, on June 23, 2026. She is survived by her loving husband Tom Rescigno, physicist and Board Director of LVO.

Many of us are familiar with the notion that children only know their parents as parents, and not as others do. That concept extends to adults who know others only in limited contexts, as did I know Erie only in her final act and only in her professional capacity. So attending her tribute was eye opening.

Tom and Erie at their wedding celebration.

At a stunningly well conceived and executed tribute organized on November 11 by her colleagues at LVO, it was fascinating to see Erie from many different perspectives and through the whole of her life. The overarching finding was that her inner and outer beauty and her determination and quest for excellence were with her throughout.

The love and respect for Erie was evident through those who contributed freely to the event. Many volunteers organized and worked tirelessly to make the tribute professional and entertaining. Livermore’s Bankhead Theater, home of LVO, contributed its 500 seat theater free of charge. And seven outstanding opera singers sang without fee.

Erie performing with Wynton Marsalis.

The evening was comprised of several tributes from friends and colleagues who had known Erie for decades; videos and audios of her work; and live performances of arias and ensembles that had meaning to Erie.

Erie sang on all of America’s great stages, including the top four of the Met, San Francisco, Lyric of Chicago, and Houston, as well as most of Europe’s great opera houses from La Scala to Vienna. She developed particularly deep relationships with Opera Theatre of St. Louis, her home town company and the preeminent American producer of opera in English language, and Santa Fe Opera, the finest summer opera company in the country.

What many don’t know is that she transitioned from her first love, which was musical theater. It was delightful to see videos of her as a charismatic and energetic young woman, and particularly her commanding rendition of Gershwin’s Naughty Baby with its high tessitura. Even that early, she revealed a vocal clarity and power with a ringing vibrato that had to find its way into opera.

Erie as Cunegonde from Candide.

Growing up in Granite City, Illinois, a suburb of St. Louis, she launched as a teen at St. Louis Muni, which (finally) won the Tony Award as Best Regional Theater in the U.S. this year. As a personal aside and a sharing with Erie, my first musical theater experience was also several shows at St. Louis Muni, and now I vote on the Regional Theater Tony Award, which included the Muni’s win.

In Clark Bason’s tribute, he told of Erie’s early days after moving to New York. She was invited by Hal Prince to be in the all-star cast of the concert version of Steven Sondheim’s Follies and sing a duet with the legendary opera soprano Licia Albanese. But before accepting the gig, she naively asked Bason if she should do it?!?! Happily, she did, and the recorded album won a Grammy.

Bason related Erie’s debut as Cunegonde in Bernstein’s Candide at New York City Opera. The conductor’s name was Joseph Rescigno. Through that link, she met his brother, a guy named Tom, whom she would marry after courtship in San Francisco. Following Bason’s remarks, the audience was treated to Erie’s rendition of “Glitter and be gay,” from the 1982 New York City Opera’s recording of Candide, which also won her a Grammy.

Erie as Lucia di Lammermoor.

President of the LVO board Jonathan Kleid also gave a warm and masterful tribute. It was surprising to learn that they had been dear friends since 1985, when Erie made her San Francisco Opera debut. It seems that Erie rented Jonathan’s apartment while she was performing and he was away. But before hand, they met and had a dinner together. Over Jonathan’s protestations as to who should pay the bill, Erie grabbed it first and intoned, “I’ll pay. I’m a diva!”

Kudos to the talented artists who sang and who are among the Bay Area’s finest – sopranos Avery Boettcher, Christie Conover, and Amy Owens; mezzo Courtney Miller; tenor James Flora; and baritones Eugene Brancoveanu and Robert Mellon. All were in fine voice and gave fantastic performances.

The singers, accompanied by a full orchestra conducted by LVO Music Director Alex Katsman, offered nine arias and ensembles. They were remarkably flawless and of high quality, especially as prepared for a single performance. Personal favorites were “Io son l’unile ancella” from Adriana Lecouvreur (Boettcher), “Donde lieta usci” from La Boheme (Conover), “Ch’ella mi creda libero e lontano” from La Fanciulla del West (Flora), and the trio from Cosi Fan Tutte (Boettcher, Miller, Brancoveanu). Appropriately, the finale was “Make our garden grow” from Candide, sung by all of the artists.

Erie Mills.

The tribute was a fitting farewell to a great friend and great lover of the opera. Rest in peace, Erie.

The Secret Museum

Johnny Moreno, Arwen Anderson. All photos by Cynthia Smalley.

Author Lynne Kaufman has carved an admirable niche creating intimate, dramatic, small cast, biographical plays.  A pre-eminent, but by no means exclusive, producer of those works has been San Francisco’s The Marsh, an esteemed and prolific presenter of new works.  Frequent collaborator Warren David Keith also participates once again as director.

Otherwise consistent with this oeuvre, Kaufman’s script for this engrossing world premiere about erotic exploration, more from an intellectual than a lascivious perspective, is from completely original material.   The cast expands from the usual one or two actors to four, though only two appear at a time, as the vignettes are primarily about relationships.  Making the narrative more compelling, the performers are drawn from among the brightest stars in the Bay Area constellation.

Characters and time stamps of the action yo-yo engrossingly between denizens of Pompeii immediately before the historic eruption of Vesuvius and contemporary contributors to the arts.  The plotline centers on the opening of a museum in Naples that celebrates previously banned art with a sexual focus, especially on the erect phallus, which appears to have been given much artistic attention in (who knew?) sexy old Pompeii.

Lyndsy Kail, Joseph O’Malley.

A new fresco has been unearthed from the Pompeii ash, and an American film maker (portrayed by Arven Anderson) with a sexual and feminist bent seeks an exclusive viewing to include in an upcoming documentary film.  It just so happens that the director of the museum (Johnny Moreno) is a former lover of hers.  Thus, she is confident of receiving the favor, but conflict dominates their interaction.

The play’s concept and execution engage throughout, a sequence of dialogues between and a man and a woman.  Some audience members could be a little confused by the frequent scene shifts between characters and times, especially with actors playing multiple roles, though I did not find that a problem.

Kaufman’s intent in The Secret Museum seems clear.  It should be interpreted very much through the lens of sexual stereotyping, rejecting the impositions that men have traditionally placed on women.  The dominant realm is the sexual and its influence on relationships.  In the focal couples and in different ways, the unbridled woman pursues and the man demurs, making for unconventional, but in many ways, refreshing sex roles. 

The other realm is the arts.  In each couple, the woman is the artist, and in different ways, the man objects to the woman’s independence and creativity which he feels should be reserved for men.

Joseph O’Malley, Lyndsy Kail.

Moreno and Anderson are no strangers to Kaufman’s work, as the pair also starred in her play about Anaïs Nin, Shameless Hussy, premiered at The Marsh last year.  It too dealt with a woman breaking free from societal constraints.

What is particularly interesting in The Secret Museum is their very different, yet equally captivating acting styles.  Indeed, they are reminiscent of Marlon Brando and Kim Hunter in the film Streetcar Named Desire.

Moreno is heavily affected with a percussive speaking style, dramatic facial expression, and integrating body movement from neck to knees as if a boxer bobbing and weaving.  Conversely, Anderson seems restrained and naturalistic, as if she were carrying on a conversation guided by a Spencer Tracy dictum of “Don’t act, just speak your lines.”  As her character is American and he is Italian, the contrast of cross-cultural chalk and cheese works. Their clashes over a number of topics rivets and begs the question what attracted them to one another in the past. There is also some surprise when one of them tries to rekindle the flame.

The other couple is a real-life couple, and it’s nice to see them spark when they get an opportunity to share the stage, especially facing off in numerous relationship roles.  In the play’s opening vignette, Joseph O’Malley plays Apollo, the god representing wisdom and order, while Lyndsy Kail plays Dionysus, the god of festivity and fertility.  What may at first seem disconnected to the narrative resolves as we see in each dyad of characters the respective traits that the gods represent.  A minor point is that while a cognate of the name Apollo is used in both Greek and Roman mythology, Dionysus is a Greek god, and it is unclear why his Roman counterpart Bacchus would not be used in the play.

Johnny Moreno, Arwen Anderson.

Kail effectively impacts and exudes composure in each of her manifestations (womanifestations?).  Although she is more ebullient and charming in some of her other characters, I particularly like her as an English painter whose affect belies what she is saying – very English actually.  O’Malley distinguishes himself as he shows the greatest range among the actors from the furious Pompeiian husband who insists that his wife heed his demands to the prudish and mousy English husband who can’t believe what he’s hearing from his wife.

Kudos again to the superb acting ensemble for endowing each character with the distinctiveness intended. The playwright’s exploration of these relationships makes for provocative fare, and the play deserves to be extended to full-length to become more marketable. One specific modification to the script going forward might be to increase or emphasize the stakes and therefore the tension. Inadequate conflict tends to be the Achilles heel of relationship fare that doesn’t quite make it.

The Secret Museum, a world premiere, is written by Lynne Kaufman and plays at The Marsh, 1062 Valencia Street, San Francisco, CA through November 22, 2026.

The Marriage of Figaro

Slávka Zámečniková as Susanna, Peter Kellner as Figaro. All photos by Cory Weaver.

En route to War Memorial Opera House, my wife and editor Karin declared, “I think I’ve had enough of Marriage” (I think she meant “of Figaro,” and not our five decades of connubial bliss!) to which I was silent.  This would be our seventh Marriage, including the same San Francisco Opera production from 2019, and notwithstanding our reluctance, its place as one of the great comedies, if not the finest in all opera, cannot be denied.

Cast. (Center) Slávka Zámečniková as Susanna, Simone McIntosh as Cherubino, Peter Kellner as Figaro.

On the plus side for the evening, it was Halloween, and it is fun to see kids and many young adults festooned and frolicking in their fanciful costumes, with even some patrons at the opera participating.  Also, since it was the end of Daylight Savings Time, we got an extra hour on our clock which compensated for the late night from an opera approaching four hours in length.  However, most historic was the supertitle flashed to a great ovation just before curtain-up, that the Golden State Valkyries (Hello, Richard Wagner) won the WNBA championship in their second year, the earliest for a major professional sports team in American history.

Slávka Zámečniková as Susanna, Thomas Mole as Count Almaviva.

But what made the evening a trifecta-plus is that the production of The Marriage of Figaro was fantastic, and both Karin and I enjoyed it tremendously.  Though the staging, which moves the action to the late 18th century in the United States, is from the 2019 production, the cast is new.  It’s hard to distinguish the quality of the singing among the performers as they are all stellar, without a weak link.  How many times can you say rich vibrato, impressive range, and full sound?

Alek Shrader as Don Basilio, Catherine Cook as Marcellina, Maurizio Muraro as Dr. Bartolo.

Also notable – individually and collectively, the comic delivery excels.  For this we must recognize the guidance of Director Shawna Lucey, whose understanding of movement, timing, and delivery are impeccable.  Though much humor of wit and manners is in the libretto, it requires the physical delivery of faces mugging, arms flailing, jumping out of windows, and hiding under sheets and skirts.  All of this is done with great flair.

Olivia Smith as the Countess, Simone McIntosh as Cherubino.

Rarely can an opera sustain the level of amusement that this does, and if it does grow stale toward the end, we can blame librettist Lorenzo da Ponte and composer Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart for not recognizing when enough is enough.  Of course, in their day, the audience wanted their money’s worth, and they didn’t have to contend with a 6 a.m. conference call to the East Coast the following morning; the babysitter’s meter ticking on overtime; or the shortened attention span in an electronic age.

The main thread running through the narrative is that the Count’s valet Figaro (an ebullient and magnetic Peter Kellner) is to marry the Countess’s maid Susanna (a clever and determined Slávka Zámečniková, Kellner’s real-life wife!), but Count Almaviva (Thomas Mole, following on another brilliant performance of a lousy character as James in Mary, Queen of Scots) has invoked the droit du seigneur, which allows the lord of the manor to have his way with the female servant before the nuptials.  Needless to say, neither the Countess (Olivia Smith in a compelling breakthrough role) nor the engaged couple is pleased with this prospect, so much ado concerns the strategy to avoid the bedding.  Incidentally, today, we just look at the plot as silly, but the humiliation of nobles by servants was highly controversial in its time, and state censors had to be accommodated.

Peter Kellner as Figaro, Olivia Smith as the Countess, Slávka Zámečniková as Susanna.

Another angle in the story concerns the hormonal odyssey of the page Cherubino (brightly animated Simone McIntosh), most critically, his flirtations with the Countess who feels abandoned by her husband.  The role of the charming but indelicate page is one of the most famous and significant trousers roles in opera, with the boy performed by a female mezzo.  In this opera, the device works particularly well because Cherubino will later appear as a female.

While the action gets complexer and complexer and drags a bit in Acts 3 and 4, the brilliant music carries on.  The ensembles throughout are numerous and striking.  When an older woman, Marcellina (witchy-looking SF Opera legend Catherine Cook) insists that Figaro must marry her to satisfy a debt, the wonderful Act 2 ending sextet ensues with each character commenting on the complicated situation.  Another ensemble highlight is the ethereal “Sull’aria” (“on the breeze”, known as “The Letter Duet”) in which the Countess and Susanna reveal the mistaken identity ruse in which Cherubino will stand in for Susanna in an assignation with the Count.

Simone McIntosh as Cherubino, Sofia Gotch as Barbarina.

As rich as Mozart’s music is, two of his most memorable arias in Marriage build on simple yet elegant phrases, both of which are delivered with great care.  One is “Voi che sapete” (“You who know what love is”) in which the young Cherubino admits to great confusion about falling in love.  Conversely, the Countess’s soliloquy “Dove sono?” (“Where am I?”), is from one who has experience and laments the lost days of her love with the Count.  There are many other set pieces of note, and we shouldn’t forget Figaro’s famously jaunty and totally hummable “Non più andrai” (“No longer will you go”).

There are some other surprises which add to the fun. For those who don’t know, Rossini’s comic opera The Barber of Seville is a prequel, and two other interesting characters carry over from the earlier story, the handkerchief waving music master Don Basilio (clarion tenor Alek Shrader) and the now distrusting and vengeful Dr. Bartolo (fine bass Maurizio Muraro).  And while one could wax on about The Marriage of Figaro, the virtues of the opera and this production should be apparent.

Cast. (foreground) Olivia Smith as the Countess, Thomas Mole as Count Almaviva.

The Marriage of Figaro, composed by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, with libretto by Lorenzo da Ponte, and based on the play La Folle Journée, ou Le Mariage de Figaro by Pierre-Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais is produced by San Francisco Opera and appears on its stage at War Memorial Opera House, 301 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA through November 29, 2026.

Betrayal

Charlie Semine as Robert, Liz Sklar as Emma, Tasso Feldman as Jerry. All photos by David Allen.

By large consensus, monogamy has become the accepted form of conjugal relationship worldwide, both legally and morally.  Yet, defiance of the standard is rife, suggesting that the convention’s hold is tenuous.  Nevertheless, breaches involving sexual activities often inflict psychological pain and are usually punished.  But measurement is not as simple as an on-off switch.  Duration may count. And sometimes reciprocity enters the equation.  For instance, did one party do something that triggered an affair by the other, and are the respective offenses equivalencies?

With Betrayal from Harold Pinter, we have one of the greats from one of the greats, a hugely award-winning play full of dark humor, pathos, conflict, and questions of loyalty.  An added dimension is that the play is semi-autobiographical, at least to the extent that Pinter had an affair for several years, which probably prompted the theme for this play.  And as the central theme, it is easy to identify the cuckolded husband as the one betrayed, but betrayal can run in any direction, including to self.

Liz Sklar as Emma, Tasso Feldman as Jerry.

Not that everybody will find Betrayal their cup of tea (tea being appropriate as the play does take place in London).  Its edges are sharp and its characters deeply flawed, so if your idea of good theater is characters that you can root for, this probably doesn’t work for you.  Then again, Death of a Salesman, Glengarry Glen Ross, Sweeney Todd, most of Shakespeare’s histories and tragedies, and a wide collection of the greatest theatrical offerings ever written probably don’t either.

Carey Perloff is a noted interpreter of Pinter’s works, having a personal history with the playwright, and we are in excellent hands with her direction.  Viewers who are engaged in the narrative will find the time flies by quickly, and even if we don’t love the characters, we are interested in their stories.  Essentially a three-hander, the love triangle comprises Emma, an art gallery executive; Robert, her husband and publisher of modern works of fiction; and Jerry, an agent, whose star client’s books are published by Robert, who doesn’t think much of the author’s works, but they do help “pay the rent.”

Like Emma and Robert, Jerry is also comfortably married, and both couples have two children.  Robert and Jerry are good friends going back to high school, so that professional success and family relationships suggest exemplary lives rather than a surreptitious affair between Emma and Jerry that has gone on for seven years.

Liz Sklar as Emma, Charlie Semine as Robert.

The interesting device in Betrayal is that while the time of the action spans the years 1968 to 1977, for the greater part, it is told backward in a very clever and largely understandable manner.  Thus, we know the outcome at the outset, but we are still interested to know why and how the characters got to that point.  Although there are nine scenes, most all occur with only two characters in the intimacy, indeed claustrophobia, of a room in a house or flat.

Given the required secrecy and logistics involved to carry on an affair, the longer it goes, the more complicated and risky it becomes.  Though it must be said, it would have been easier back then before cell phones, tracking technology, and the like that limit unexplained absences.  But apart from the ability to have unexplained time, other issues remain.

Tasso Feldman as Jerry, Charlie Semine as Robert.

The playwright introduces a number of auxiliary issues. Characters repeat the same question at different times and elicit different answers.  Are respondents compulsively untruthful, or do the same past events trigger memory in a dissimilar way depending on the context?

With Emma and Jerry, does Robert know about the affair, and if so, when did he learn, and why has he said nothing, and does he care?  As discreet as the lovers think they’ve been, do other people know, and do they talk about it behind their backs?  Have either of them divulged information about the lover to the spouse that they wouldn’t be expected to know?   And what about unexpected events?  Pinter surfaces these potential stumbling blocks and more.  At the same time, he doesn’t present the perpetrators as villains, but just as people with complex lives that inevitably lead to conflict.

The cast is first rate with naturalistic acting including the pauses and uhs that reflect real life conversations. Marin Theatre favorite Sklar is the charming, emotional, and usually effervescent Emma with her conflicted loyalties as she tries to balance her relationship with two men and maintain her professional life. Charlie Semine portrays Robert as a phlegmatic and reflective man who finds himself out of his element professionally, preferring to read Yeats’s poetry and generally disdaining prose. Perhaps he feels out of his element in other ways as well.  And Tasso Feldman is Jerry.  Always matter of fact, he talks a good relationship game, but is he really loyal, or is he merely the opportunist that we expect agents to be? Pinter leaves much open to our speculation.

Charlie Semine as Robert, Tasso Feldman as Jerry, Liz Sklar as Emma.

Betrayal, written by Harold Pinter, is produced by Marin Theatre and plays on its stage at 397 Miller Avenue, Mill Valley, CA through November 15, 2026.

The Lion in Winter

Daron Jennings as Henry, Katina Psihos as Eleanor. All photos by ACT OUT Photography (by Jim Norrena).

Some movies are so riveting and memorable that one wonders why a theater group would want to mount a stage production and fare poorly by comparison.  Such is the film The Lion in Winter, loved by audiences and critics alike, and with a haul of Oscar nominations and wins.  Peter O’Toole and Katherine Hepburn seethe and tear up the screen with breathtaking performances that are beyond biting and actually over-the-top.

Not to be intimidated, Altarena Playhouse has taken up the challenge, and disproving the pessimistic hypothesis, offers a totally rewarding rendering of James Goldman’s witty script about the unending political machinations of a massively dysfunctional royal family.  The playwright remains true to the significant historical points, while the interplay among the characters is fanciful, but gripping.

Daron Jennings as Henry, Sydney Harmon as Alais, Katina Psihos as Eleanor, Dominic Antonich as John.

The time is the late 1100s, and Henry II of England is first in the line of Plantagenet kings.  His rule extends to much of France, partly enhanced by his marriage to Eleanor of Aquitaine.  However, Eleanor and their eldest still-living son Richard, who would become Richard the Lionheart, led a rebellion against Henry, with the result that Eleanor was arrested.

At the time of the play’s action, Eleanor is in her tenth year of imprisonment, yet she retains power, leverage, and in this telling, a delightfully complex relationship with her husband and jailer, in part because she still exercises control over Aquitaine.  The battle between the couple is largely over succession, with Eleanor supporting Richard and Henry supporting John, the youngest son.  In time, both would become king, while the surviving middle son, Geoffrey, would be the odd man out, supported by neither parent.

Daron Jennings as Henry, Sydney Harmon as Alais.

Katina Psihos is Altarena’s artistic director, and it seems pretty clear why she chose this project.  She steps back onto the stage as Eleanor, with an absolutely triumphant performance in a role that couldn’t suit her better.  Her Eleanor is imperious yet fragile and loving yet cruel, and in a microcosm where flippancy is expected and valued, she is a master.  At one moment, her intimacy with Henry belies her incarceration, and in the next, she all but challenges him to execute her. Psihos’s acting intelligence is off the charts, using every facial feature with expressive exactitude.  Likewise, her vocal quality carries the right lilt and demonstrativeness appropriate to each situation.

Meanwhile, Henry is late middle aged but depicted as highly hormonal, flaunting at Eleanor his carnal relationship with the younger Alais (Sydney Harmon).  Now, read this about the complexities of the relationships.  The vulnerable Alais, Princess and half-sister of Philip II of France (Ryan Chu), was betrothed to Richard (Colin Epstein) at age 8 and sent to live under Henry’s protection.  Eleanor was her surrogate mother.  Yet, despite all, Henry, has made Alais his public mistress (historically, there were rumors, but no proof of this liaison).

Ryan Chu as Philip, Colin Epstein as Richard.

Daron Jennings provides an apt and full-fleshed portrayal of Henry – insightful, eloquent, and manipulative – standing toe-to-toe with Eleanor and largely bellowing at her and the sons that they both find a disgrace.  But Jennings also finds a sensitive side in the character, and despite his bluster, leaves doors open for options.  And like his distaff, it’s hard at times to know when they are being truthful and when they are deceiving.

In this turmoil, the three sons conspire against their parents and one another and often without attempt for deception.  Richard is a particular bull in the china shop, while the intellect among them is the acerbic Geoffrey, who is played with sardonic flair by Julian Dion.

Dominic Antonic as John, Julian Dion as Geoffrey, Ryan Chu as Philip.

The most unfathomable aspect of the frail alliances within the corrupt family rests with the way John (Dominic Antonich) is written.  He is such a simpleton that it begs the question why Henry wishes John to succeed him, other than the fact that John was not involved in the rebellion.  In truth, Eleanor did support John after the death of Richard, but that may have been simply because of blood and her perceived ability to control him.  Incidentally, it was John who was forced to sign the Magna Carta, after all of the other family members were gone.

Director Angela Mason’s pacing of the play with its witty badinage, questioning of motives, and never-ending conspiratorial strategies makes the evening fly by.  The acting of the two main principals carries the day, and while the rest are generally okay, there are some instances of overacting and less convincing portrayals.  In part dictated by the several different venues needed, the staging is basic, but with some elegant trappings. However, the script is so compelling and the delivery so sharp that it really doesn’t matter.  This production entertains.

Katina Psihos as Eleanor, Dominic Antonich as John, Julian Dion as Geoffrey, Colin Epstein as Richard.

The Lion in Winter, written by James Goldman is produced by Altarena Playhouse and is performed on its stage at 1409 High Street, Alameda, CA through November 22, 2026.

Manon

Pene Pati as Chevalier des Grieux, Amina Edris as Manon. All photos by Cory Weaver.

It’s too long.  Act One drags, yet life altering events fly by in a flash and without prologue.  The drama is clunky and inexplicable at times, but that’s French opera for you.  Situations are too reminiscent of La Traviata (though Manon’s source material is earlier).  Finally, the austere set is comprised of a bleak, white tapered wall. The verdict?

Though flawed, and what isn’t, Manon is a masterpiece.  Along with Werther, it deservedly remains one of the composer’s two most popular operas.  Massenet mastered melody, so the music enchants throughout, and the characters captivate.  What’s more, the San Francisco Opera production is a delight.  And in this realization, the lead couple own their roles.  They both spark and sparkle with uncommon chemistry, perhaps because they’re married in real life and get to have extra rehearsal time together in their lodgings!

Laura Krumm as Javotte, Stephen Gaertner as De Brétigny, Sofia Gotch as Poussette, Steven Cole as Guillot de Morfontaine, and Taylor Raven as Rosette.

While Massenet and his librettists may have faltered in their dramatic thrust, they have produced one of opera’s great femme fatale lead characters with multiple dimensions, or at least evolution.  The young Manon, who was to be sent to a convent because of her reckless behavior as an adolescent, shows impulsiveness as she quickly accedes to Chevalier des Grieux’s hasty marriage proposal and runs off with him.  She admits to her envy of rich young women adorned in jewelry, evidenced by a bright, delightful acapella mezzo trio.  But her quest for riches is not likely to be fulfilled in her arrangement with des Grieux.

Buffeted by conflicting desires, she allows her betrothed to be abducted in return for the promise of marriage into great wealth.  But in another about-face, she ultimately returns to des Grieux driven by what would appear to be a genuine reflection of love, and she seeks redemption.

Pene Pati as Chevalier des Grieux and Vitor Bispo as Lescaut.

Former Adler Fellow at San Francisco Opera, Amina Edris returns as one of the great contemporary interpreters of this role, which she has performed around the world.  In voice and action, she captures every aspect of Manon with precision from the flighty ingenue looking to escape a doleful future to the tragic lover.

Her voice possesses a warm timbre and vibrato throughout her range, navigating the coloratura elements with relish, especially when she trumpets her new-found high-society notoriety in the famed “Je marche sur tous les chemins” (“I walk all the streets”) and the following gavotte “Obéissons quand leur voix appelle” (“Obey when their voices call”) in Act 3.  The role demands lyric lushness which Edris provides, but not the power that a dramatic soprano role would.  Indeed, in her duets she doesn’t quite maintain the desired volume balance with the tenor.

Amina Edris as Manon.

Like his wife, Pene Pati was also a well-loved Adler Fellow who has taken on many title roles especially in some of Europe’s top houses.  A tenor of the highest order, his voice excels in its strength, enthusiasm, and clarity, without the strained or pinched sound of many others in this voice range.  His acting meets opera’s highest demands, with his passionate best directed at Manon, from gambling party scenes to unrestrained love to near violent rejection and ultimate tragedy.  The composer also endows this role with a number of melodious arias, the most memorable being the lament he conquers when entering the religious world and leaving his love behind, “Ah fuyez douce image” (“Oh vanish sweet memory”). 

Massenet offers more than just show-stopping arias for the lovers.  A strong chorus and ensemble pieces, including a foreboding quartet and duets for the lovers, play a large role.  Secondary characters are significant, all of which are male.  Most notable is the Comte des Grieux, the Chevalier’s inconsolable and interfering father, akin to Traviata’s Giorgio Germont.   Portrayed by James Creswell, the compelling bass displays particular ease and volume consistency throughout his range while maintaining model diction.

Amina Edris as Manon and Stephen Gaertner as De Brétigny.

Back to the staging which can make a significant difference in the vibrancy and appeal of an opera.  Like Maya Lin’s gash, as the Viet Nam War Memorial was often derisively called, it may take a while for the viewer to respect Director Vincent Boussard and Set Designer Vincent Lemaire’s minimalistic set.

But in the end, it works brilliantly as a versatile canvas.  Variously imbued with light, shadow, reflection, and projection, and while occasionally set off by symbolic props and rich splashes of color, the formerly empty space fills the eye with everything from balloons to crucifixion symbols.  A parapet running the length of the wall at one time displays a cityscape of Paris and acts as a linear platform for crowds.  And when the gargantuan chorus floods the stage, it is not lost in the scenery but looks and acts as an organic whole. A final mention goes again to Boussard, who is also responsible for the sumptuous costume design which adds another stunning visual element.

Pene Pati as Chevalier des Grieux, Amina Edris as Manon.

Manon, composed by Jules Massenet with libretto by Henri Meilhac and Philippe Gille, is produced by San Francisco Opera and plays at War Memorial Opera House, 301 Van Ness Ave., San Francisco, CA through November 1, 2026.

Alchemists change something ordinary into something extraordinary. That can be said of Alkemē Restaurant’s chef-owner Hue-Chan Karels and executive chef and general manager Erica Tai. They have created a menu of healthy, nurturing Vietnamese-centric food in Santa Fe, New Mexico that combines Michelin quality and taste with peasant history and tradition. So, if you’re expecting and wanting normal inexpensive American/Vietnamese fare, you’ll be disappointed.

Santa Fe has become a foodie paradise, having probably more restaurants with award recognition per capita than any other American city. Although some Santa Fe restaurants are over 100 years old, there are many and diverse newcomers including Alkemē, James Beard-nominated Best New Restaurant in 2024. Edible Magazine named Alkemē Local Hero Best Restaurant as it celebrated its third anniversary in June, 2026.

The restaurant combines fine dining with family hospitality.  Hostess and servers are friendly and knowledgeable about the food history and recipe ingredients. Wall leaf paintings adorned in colors of green, gold and black, along with Asian lanterns dominate the décor.  Along with the accompaniment of soft jazzy/bluesy music, a very calming ambience results.

A choice of a tasting menus, land or sea ($85) and a vegetarian option ($75), has suggestions for accompanying delectable craft cocktails, wines, and beers, or diners can choose a la carte.  A la carte allows individual entrée choices ranging from $16 to $39. All the food is inventive and complex.

Ingredients often sound simple but the flavors harmonize and honor the Vietnamese tradition, spirit, and journey. Every dish is handmade each day. Many of the ingredients are brought from Vietnam. For example, I enjoyed a sweet/tart “Violet Crown” cocktail comprised of Vietnamese butterfly pea flower infused vodka, fresh lime juice, fresh ginger, house made ginger syrup and egg white. So the cocktails as well as the food have healing nourishing ingredients.

One of the wonderful starters is a Carrot soup designed and developed during Covid for delivery by owner Hue-Chan to nurture, heal, and boost the immune system. The handmade, vegan, gluten-free, nut-free vegetable broth laced with ginger, turmeric, coconut milk, and spiced carrot crisps sounds quite simple yet possesses a rich, complex palate that was perhaps my favorite of the many delicious dishes.  It was named as a favorite by a number of diners I interviewed.

Chef-owner Hue-Chan Karels.

Other mouthwatering appetizers include Turmeric crispy cod with dill aioli, Vietnamese herb oil, fennel-jicama-green apple slaw, and pickled red onions; Citrus-cured yellowfin tuna with tamarind-fish sauce, pickled Asian pear, red chili essence, rau ram, and crisp rice paper; and Rice turmeric crepe with pork belly, vegetables, and herbs. All of these and more choices can be ordered vegan and gluten-free.

Like the appetizers, main course influences come from throughout Vietnam, and many are vegetarian or pescatarian.  Notable meat choices include Hanoi-style grilled pork noodles. The fine cut rice noodles are complemented with picked green papaya and carrot, in a warm lime/fish broth sweetened with palm sugar and an abundance of tender grilled pork patties and slices. Another favorite is the Broken rice with duck fat confit umami chicken leg (yes – that’s one name!) with Red Boat fish sauce and salt-cured, pork-egg terrine. It is worth noting that many dishes include broken rice. This is the rice that the Vietnamese peasants kept for their own nourishment after collecting the whole rice for sale.

Portions are sumptuous, generous, filling, and enough to take home for at least one more meal. If diners can manage more food, they might be tempted to try one of several dessert options ($14) such as Vietnamese Coffee flan with almond meringue or Warm coconut-pandan pudding with bananas, tapioca pearls, sweet potato mochi, and toasted coconut.

Take-away can be ordered, but the experience of becoming one of Alkemē’s family by dining in should not be missed.  Enjoy as a general night out or on a celebratory special occasion with staff singing and perhaps offering some surprise extras. So if Vietnam is too far for a birthday night out, how about Santa Fe, New Mexico?

Alkemē Restaurant – 227 Don Gaspar (at the corner of W. Alameda), Santa Fe, NM. Dinner service Tuesday through Saturday 5pm to 8:45pm. Welcomes children over 5years. Dress: business casual.

Every Saturday Night: A Harlem of the West Musical

Cathleen Riddley as Ardella, Rob Robinson as Uncle Bob. All photos by Alexa LexMex Treviño

Change happens.  So it was in 1956 with the real-world urban development that would reshape San Francisco’s diverse and largely black Fillmore District, displacing over 10,000 people.  The world premiere musical Every Saturday Night….. centers on a broken black family facing the uncertainties of the project.    The proceedings intermittently flash forward to present day when only the now elderly son of the family remains alive.  The musical also reveals the enterprise of the oppressed in dealing with disadvantage and the bonds that people shared in their spare time when they were free to be themselves.

A friendly opening night audience roared with support.  This labor of love possesses numerous strengths, but like many premieres, the work does need some work.

Imri M. Tate as Doris.

Ardella (Cathleen Riddley) managed to buy a house in The Fillmore because of supplementary earnings from operating After Hours, an unlicensed club, at her home every Saturday night, charging for booze and chicken dinners and providing music for guests to dance to.  The animated parties with song and dance create an upbeat vibe and escape for all involved, and the party sequences play a big role in the feel-good aspect of the play. 

The music throughout is catchy and does help the story along.  Though not a fault as such, what does surprise a bit is the conventional sound of the tunes, like a typical stage musical.  Particularly in the 1950s, The Fillmore was a center for jazz and blues, but those influences on the music in the play are minimal, with the exception of one song with scat riffs and the occasional bluesy chord in a couple of others.

RJ Wayne as Bobby Joe.

Despite many light touches, the story bulges with social issues.  One particularly incisive and reflective one revolves around Christine (the acting highlight of the show – a delightful, flamboyant Velina Brown), who is with the neighborhood heritage society in the contemporary period of the play.  As well intended as she and her group are, they are intervening in the real estate market to try to ensure that the “right kind of people” settle in the neighborhood, which in large measure repeats the motivation of the earlier urban renewal project, but with social class rather than racial implications.

Another issue concerns Ardella’s adolescent son Donte (Jacob Henrie-Naffaa), who has hidden from her the fact that he is acting in a play as Peter Pan.  The circumstances that surround the issue deal with parent-child communication and extend to homosexuality, which is implied but not expressed.

Jacob Henrie-Naffaa as young Donte.

Use of the same space to tell two different stories in alternating fashion with only one overlapping character is clever.  A particularly effective design orchestrated by Director AeJay Antonis Marquis is sequences when both the characters from the ‘50s and from today are on the stage together and their dialogues interspersed.  The execution didn’t live up to its potential at opening, but hopefully it will improve.

Most of the performers seem to be primarily actors, and the singing is uneven, with only Imri M. Tate as Doris displaying a strong voice.  A couple of numbers seem that they would benefit singers by being sung in a different key, and one of young Donte’s that requires the performer to shift registers does no one any favors.

Darryl V. Jones as old Donte, Trevor Miller as Adarè.

The appealing production, directed and choreographed by AeJay Antonis Marquis, features handsome staging led by Sarah Phykitt’s single set that serves as the venue for all of the action.  Notably, Marquis provides extensive and energetic dance and Amber Julian the considerable hair, wig, and makeup demands.

Although the story of a whole black community being dispossessed by a disastrous urban renewal program resonates, it fails to explain the magnitude of what actually happened; why Ardella’s home was spared; the fictionalized effect on other characters; or the recent disgrace of Justin Herman who was a major architect and executor of the program.  This is despite the significance of the falling out between Ardella and her tenant Doris in the play over whether to protest the project.  A brief narrative in the latter time frame from Older Donte (Darryl V. Jones) to the prospective home buyers would be appropriate.

Trevor Miller as Adarè, Velina Brown as Christine La Fontaine, (seated) Darryl V. Jones as old Donte, (standing) Janelle La Salle as Joanelle, Jon-David Randle as Samuel.

The storyline will interest Bay Area aficionados and those concerned with how minority groups have been maltreated in so many ways.  For the musical to have legs, the question is whether the universality of the minority plight can overcome the narrow geographical focus of the issue.

Every Saturday Night: A Harlem of the West Musical with music and lyrics by Danny Duncan and book by Michael Gene Sullivan and Danny Duncan is produced by San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Company and appears at Strand Theater, 1127 Market Street, San Francisco, CA through November 1, 2026.

The Abduction from the Seraglio

Michelle Allie Drever as Konstanze, Kirk Eichelberger as Pasha Selim. All photos by Otak Jump.

Other than Idomeneo, Abduction from the Seraglio (Die Entführung aus dem Serail) is Mozart’s earliest composed “opera” that remains in the repertoire.  However, it is really a classic singspiel with a considerable amount of dialog.  A vital role, the Pasha Selim, is even a completely spoken role, though performed by the accomplished bass Kirk Eichelberger.  As many deficiencies as bedevil this piece, it works on its own terms, as an engaging narrative with beautiful and challenging music.  West Bay Opera has produced a captivating version of the work.

The opera largely concerns the clash of European and Middle Eastern values.  Three Europeans who were captured by pirates have been sold to the Turkish Pasha Selim, whose factotum Osmin, actually the chaperone of the Pasha’s harem, often acts as his gatekeeper.  Belmonte, the Spanish fiancé of Konstanze, one of the captives, arrives in search of her.  Belmonte engages with the ill-tempered Osmin, who provides resistance rather than assistance.

Chorus.

Osmin is stereotyped as a Muslim who holds Europeans in low opinion and treats them accordingly. Conversely, the libretto depicts the Pasha kindly, as he refrains from forcing himself on Konstanze, even though he is greatly attracted to her and could simply command that she accept his advances.  The action of course centers on the efforts to free the prisoners from the grasp of Pasha, and ends with some interesting, if improbable, twists.  Note that the composer and librettist’s (Gottlieb Stephanie) deference to the Pasha flies in the face of Austrian antipathy toward Turks as the Ottomans had twice sieged Vienna, most recently a century before the opera.

Abduction opens with a lively and familiar overture that foretells some of the themes that follow.  In addition to traditional Baroque music, Mozart also introduces some Turkish musical idioms that enrich the score.

Caleb Alexander as Pedrillo, Casey Germain as Osmin, Hak Soo Kim as Belmonte.

The young composer did present challenges for lead principals, which each surmounts.  Michelle Allie Drever is a wonderful Konstanze.  Drever displays a penetrating and mellifluous voice.  Her Act 1 reflective aria “Ach ich liebte, war so glüchlich!” (“Ah, I was in love, I was so happy”) is the apotheosis of virtuosity – full of sparkling coloratura riffs, leaps, and roller-coaster arpeggios.

Yet, her Act 2 aria “Marten aller Arten” (“Tortures of every kind”), in expectation of the degradation she faces, is considered even more difficult.  Why?  Not only is the aria itself a demanding eight-minute ordeal, but it comes on the heels of a lead-in eight-minute aria, testing the endurance of the soprano singing the role.  Drever nails it as well.  Mozart would never again demand 16 minutes of solo singing by a single artist with only a minor break.

Lora Bashmakian as Blonde, Caleb Alexander as Pedrillo, Hak Soo Kim as Belmonte, Michelle Allie Drever as Konstanze.

Osmin, acts as the antagonist, and Casey Germain is a fine exemplar.  The bass voice must be able to sing tunefully with rich darkness in the mid and upper ranges but must also be able to plumb the depths.  Osmin’s role demands the full gamut of the bass’s voice, and Germain responds.  His memorable Act 3 aria when he ponders besting his enemies “Oh, wie will ich triumphieren” (“How triumphant I shall be”) descends to the basso profundo range to a low D.  Like most basses, Germain loses amplitude at that level, but he is impressively true and clear.

Our hero Belmonte comes to free Konstanze along with two servants.  Hak Soo Kim portrays Belmonte and delivers a warm, seemingly relaxed tenor voice.  He holds the long notes with glee and excels in all of his arias, the most notable being the beautiful ode to lovers’ reunion “Wenn der Freude Tränen fliessen” (“When tears of joy flow”). 

Cast.

The principal cast is limited to five singing parts.  The remaining two are servants Blonde (soprano Lora Bashmakian) and Pedrillo (tenor Caleb Alexander), both of whom shine in their solos.  In addition to fine arias, the composer has crafted wonderful (almost obligatory at that time) act-ending ensembles with a fine trio ending Act 1 and a quartet of two loving couples ending Act 2.

While the opera and this particular production are delightful, the work is not without weaknesses, starting with its reliance on the spoken word which disrupts the flow of the piece. Another is repetition in both music and lyrics.  For those familiar with the movie Amadeus, you’ll recall that Emperor Joseph II questioned Mozart whether there weren’t too many notes in this opera, to which Mozart replied that each one is needed.  I would agree with the emperor.

Much of the singing takes place in the stand-and-deliver style that doesn’t integrate well with the action.  Nonetheless, in Abduction we hear music that anticipates the mature Mozart in his most polished later works that would make him one of the greatest opera composers of all time.

Caleb Alexander as Pedrillo, Michelle Allie Drever as Konstanze, Hak Soo Kim as Belmonte.

Finally, this production is visually appealing with striking costumery (Callie Floor) and set design (Peter Crompton) heavily aided by projections.  As always, Maestro José Luis Moscovich conducts the orchestra with great panache.

The Abduction from the Seraglio, composed by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart with libretto by Gottlieb Stephanie, is produced by West Bay Opera and is performed at Lucie Stern Theatre, 1305 Middlefield Road, Palo Alto, CA through October 18, 2026.