
One wonders how many words have been written about Giuseppe Verdi’s La Traviata since its premiere in 1853. A disaster at its opening, it quickly became one of the most appreciated masterpieces in the canon and the anchor to the composer’s rich middle period along with Il Travatore and Rigoletto. In many years it has been the most performed opera worldwide, and why not? With end-to-end luscious music, gaiety, romance, drama, exoticism, dance, and tragedy, all in a believable (fictionalized) storyline, what’s not to like? And remarkably, this stunningly beautiful opera was written in record time.
What made the source material, the roman à clef La Dame aux Camélias, au courant and what set salon society atwitter was that with little concealed, it tells of the recent sad existence of Parisian courtesan Marie Duplessis and her relationship with none other than the novel’s author, Alexandre Dumas fils.

The opera appeared shortly after the novel with the basic facts intact, wherein Alfredo Germont falls in love with Violetta. Unbeknownst to Alfredo, his father Georgio successfully implores her to abandon her love for the sake of Alfredo’s sister and the family honor – notwithstanding that Violetta is dying of consumption and is now without means of support. An atoned father and son come separately to Violetta’s tattered lodgings and deathbed just before she expires. The real-life Marie was 23 years old.
There is a reason that the plot of this opera is important to summarize. Francesco Maria Piave’s libretto offers social commentary, noting that the Germonts were in the highly prosperous merchant class where social mores were quite strict. The nobility that Violetta normally hung with could give a damn about the propriety of the masses.

Also, it would be difficult to find many operas in which three main characters reveal such poignant evolution in three acts. As a courtesan of the highest order, Violetta should be totally amoral, yet she falls in love with a commoner, and her caring for Alfredo and his family lead to her isolation, impoverishment, and death. Alfredo goes from being an ardent puppy dog to a petulant spurned paramour to a regretful true lover. Giorgio was driven only by the needs of his family to maintain its social position. This blinded him to the goodness of Violetta and the love that she and Alfredo shared. Too late he realizes how complete her sacrifice has been, and he becomes racked with earnest grief and guilt. This is real tear-jerking stuff.
Opera San Jose takes on this war horse once more, insightfully directed by Tara Branham who has an interesting backstage history with the opera. She takes a more literal and expressive approach than many productions, while introducing some new twists that work well, like kathak (Indian) dancing in the party scene and an amusing gender transformation. Further, Alfredo is portrayed very much as an outsider lacking the largesse of the noble class. The outcome is all you could ask for from the company, equally comfortable with the grand party scenes that fix in the memory and the intimate chamber scenes that better reveal character traits. The staging and singing are thoughtful and beautiful throughout.

Overture themes signal the wonderful music to come, and its somber opening motif foretells and bookends the closing sadness. The remainder of Act 1 contains a wealth of memorable arias and ensembles that few other operas can claim. The whole work resonates with instrumental music delivered by Conductor Johannes Löhner’s well-honed orchestra.
Violetta is regarded as a great challenge for any soprano, demanding vocal and acting versatility, reflecting the character’s many shifts in mood and physical strength. Mikayla Sager in a role debut delivers the receipts, as her dark spinto voice suits the part of a doleful and dying heroine. She commands the coloratura runs and flourishes with ease along with the emotional rollercoaster that the character suffers from the bright “Sempre libera” (“Always free”) to the gut-wrenching finale “Gran Dio!…morir sì giovane” (“Great God!…to die so young”).

Her counterpart, WooYoung Yoon as Alfredo exhibits a strong, clarion tenor voice that rings clear to the very end. It did seem that he needed a warmup at opening. Perhaps it’s unfair to have a highlight such as the lively brindisi “Libiamo ne’ lieti calici” (“Let’s drink from the joyful cups”) almost out of the gate before the singer hits stride. In a couple of places in that toasting song, Yoon seemed to get caught between major and minor intervals, but beyond that, he was on pitch and powerful.
The third major player is Giorgio Germont, performed by bass Kidon Choi who produces a big, round, warm sound backed with emotion. A fitting Giorgio, his voice, however, is a bit cloaked, and he does have a tendency to drag to dirge speed, as noted in his signature aria “Di Provenza il mar” (“Who erased the sea and the land of Provence from your heart?”

Even for those who feel they’ve seen enough of La Traviata (my tenth), this one is a joy.
La Traviata, with music by Giuseppe Verdi and libretto by Francesco Maria Piave, based on the novel La Dame aux Camélias by Alexandre Dumas fils, is produced by Opera San José and plays at California Theatre, 345 South First Street, San Jose, CA through May 3, 2026.























